Navigating the Labyrinth: Can You Place Your Ecuadorian Property into a US-Based Trust? Legal Implications for Expats

As an Ecuadorian Real Estate Attorney and Land Specialist, I have spent decades guiding foreign nationals through the intricate landscape of property acquisition in Ecuador. A recurring and critical question arises from my clients: "Can I put my Ecuadorian property into my US-based trust for asset protection or estate planning?"

The impulse to use familiar legal instruments is understandable, but let me be unequivocal: applying US legal structures directly to Ecuadorian real estate is a pathway to title complications, financial risk, and potential legal invalidity. Ecuadorian law is sovereign. Understanding its specific requirements is not optional; it is essential for securing your investment.

The Bedrock of Ecuadorian Property Law: The Registro de la Propiedad

In Ecuador, real estate ownership is not merely a matter of holding a deed. Legal ownership is perfected and proven by a single, definitive act: the registration of a notarized public deed (Escritura Pública de Compraventa) in the Registro de la Propiedad (Property Registry) of the specific canton (county) where the property is located. This registry entry is the ultimate proof of title. The system operates on the principle of tracto sucesivo—an unbroken, chronological chain of registered owners.

When you purchase property, your name—or the name of a legally constituted Ecuadorian entity—must be inscribed in this registry. Anything less is not a legally defensible claim to ownership.

The Collision: A US Trust vs. Ecuadorian Legal Reality

A US-based trust is a creature of common law, a fiduciary relationship where a trustee holds assets for beneficiaries. While highly effective within the US legal system, it encounters fundamental, and often insurmountable, barriers in Ecuador.

1. Non-Recognition by the Property Registry: The Ecuadorian Registro de la Propiedad is mandated by law to register property in the name of a legally recognized "person," either a natural person (persona natural) with a cédula or passport number, or a juridical person (persona jurídica) legally established and registered in Ecuador with a tax ID (Registro Único de Contribuyentes - RUC). A US trust does not fit into either of these categories. It is not a juridical entity under the Ecuadorian Código Civil or Ley de Compañías. A Registrar will, and legally must, reject an attempt to register title directly in the name of "The Smith Family Revocable Trust."

2. Notarial Protocol: The property transfer process requires execution of an Escritura Pública before a licensed Ecuadorian Notary. The Notary is legally obligated to verify the legal capacity and identity of both the seller and the buyer. They cannot legally validate a foreign trust as a grantee because it lacks the legal standing and identification documents required under Ecuadorian notarial law.

3. Tax and Regulatory Chaos: Attempting to overlay a foreign trust creates a legal grey area that invites scrutiny from Ecuador's tax authority, the SRI (Servicio de Rentas Internas). How are annual property taxes (impuestos prediales) assessed? Who is the legal entity responsible for declaring capital gains upon a future sale? This ambiguity can lead to severe tax penalties and complicates compliance with both US (FBAR/FATCA) and Ecuadorian regulations.

Sound Legal Alternatives vs. Dangerous Shortcuts

While direct ownership by a US trust is unworkable, secure and effective strategies exist.

• The Gold Standard: An Ecuadorian Corporation: This is the most robust and legally sound method for holding property, particularly for investment or asset protection. Forming an Ecuadorian company—most commonly a SAS (Sociedad por Acciones Simplificadas) due to its flexibility—creates a recognized legal entity. The SAS becomes the registered owner of the property. You, in turn, own the shares of the SAS. Your US trust can then be designated as the owner/beneficiary of the shares of this Ecuadorian company, creating an indirect but legally sound linkage for estate planning purposes.

• Direct Personal Ownership: For a single owner or a married couple, holding the title directly in your personal names is the most straightforward approach. Your estate can then be managed through a properly executed will. A will drafted in your home country can be recognized in Ecuador through a validation process (exequatur), though it is often more efficient to have a separate Ecuadorian will specifically for your assets here.

• ⚠️ High-Risk / Never Advised: "Nominee" Ownership: Using an Ecuadorian associate or friend to hold the title in their name while you maintain beneficial ownership is a catastrophic mistake. This creates no legally enforceable right for you. You are entirely at the mercy of the nominee, who could sell the property, encumber it with debt, or lose it to their own creditors. Ecuadorian courts will not recognize your "undeclared" interest.

Hyper-Specific Due Diligence: The Expert's Non-Negotiable Checklist

Before any discussion of ownership structure, a rigorous due diligence process is mandatory. This is where costly mistakes are prevented.

1. Master Title Verification: Demand an updated Certificado de Gravámenes y Limitaciones de Dominio from the cantonal Registro de la Propiedad. This is the property’s official legal biography. I personally review this document for:

   • Hipotecas: Active mortgages.
   • Prohibiciones de Enajenar: Court-ordered prohibitions preventing the sale of the property.
   • Embargos: Liens or seizures resulting from debt judgments.
   • Demandas: Registered lawsuits affecting the property.
   • Servidumbres: Easements or right-of-way grants that could limit your use of the land.

2. Deconstruct Proindiviso (Undivided Co-ownership) Risk: A common trap is buying "derechos y acciones" (rights and actions), which represents a percentage share of a larger, unsubdivided parcel (lote proindiviso). This does not grant you ownership of a specific, physically demarcated plot. You become a co-owner of the entire parent property, unable to get construction permits or sell your "piece" without the consent of all other co-owners or completing a complex and expensive formal subdivision (lotización) process through the municipality.

3. Scrutinize Water Rights with SENAGUA: For rural and agricultural land, water is everything. Ownership of land does not automatically grant you the right to use water from a river, spring, or well. These rights are granted by SENAGUA (National Water Secretariat). You must verify that the property has a registered water use permit (Certificado de Uso y Aprovechamiento de Agua). Many properties operate with informal or "ancestral" water use, which is not legally defensible and can be cut off at any time. The bureaucratic process to formalize unregistered water rights is arduous, can take years, and has no guarantee of success.

4. Verify Coastal and Protected Zone Compliance: Be aware of special restrictions. Any property within the coastal zone is subject to specific regulations. The Ley de Soberanía imposes limitations on foreign ownership in strategic border and coastal areas. Furthermore, construction within the zona de playa y bahía (the first 250 meters from the high tide line in urban areas, 500 in rural) requires special permits, often involving the Ministry of Defense or Naval authorities (DIGEIM), completely separate from municipal building permits.

5. Understand the Promesa vs. the Escritura: A Promesa de Compraventa is a notarized preliminary contract that obligates the parties to execute a final sale. It locks in the price and terms but it does not transfer ownership. It is a common and useful tool, but do not mistake it for the final deed. Ownership is only transferred upon the signing of the definitive Escritura Pública de Compraventa and its subsequent registration in the Registro de la Propiedad.

Conclusion: Prioritize Legal Security Over Perceived Convenience

The desire to use a US trust for Ecuadorian property stems from a wish for security and control. Ironically, attempting to do so directly achieves the opposite, creating a legally weak title that is vulnerable to challenges and administrative chaos.

The path to secure ownership in Ecuador is not through legal shortcuts but through adherence to Ecuadorian law. The most reliable method involves establishing a recognized local legal structure, like an Ecuadorian SAS company, whose shares can then be integrated into your broader international estate plan. This approach provides clear, defensible title, regulatory compliance, and true peace of mind.

Do not allow a misunderstanding of jurisdictional law to jeopardize your significant investment. Your primary goal must be to secure unimpeachable title under the laws of the Republic of Ecuador.

---

Before you sign any document, ensure your investment is built on a solid legal foundation. Contact a certified Ecuadorian real estate attorney to conduct comprehensive due diligence and structure your purchase correctly.